George Cayley invents airplane in 1825

IOTL, George Cayley figured out how to make an airplane (he even did a few glider experiments) but was unable to invent powered flight because he couldn't get the internal combustion engine to work.

Suppose he manages to get the engine to work and sees first flight in 1825. What happens?
 
For this to happen, internal combustion has to be invented decades earlier, probably at least 50 years. To accelerate things that much, your POD has to be so far back Mr. Cayley might be butterflied away.
 
Not necessarily, necessity is the mother of invention and Cayley does need an internal combustion engine to make heavier than air flight work. Wiki says he tried to make a prototypical internal combustion engine using gunpowder as fuel.

Let's say in TTL his search for an internal combustion engine puts him in contact with the Niépce brothers (who settled in England in 1817) and their Pyréolophore. Now in TTL Claude Niepce descended into delirium trying to market the Pyréolophore while his brother Nicephore went on to invent photography. In TTL Claude cooperates with Cayley with the intent of "conquering the skies" and is thus saner.

Now Claude's brother Nicephore lived until 1833 so let's say Claude lives until say 1830 or so. That gives us about a decade of collaboration with Cayley re:the internal combustion engine. Though their focus is on refining the Pyréolophore to a state where it could power an airplane, in the process the two create several workable versions of the Internal Combustion engine (perhaps using paraffin as fuel?). This could very easily lead to a world where the internal combustion engine supplants the steam engine early on, a "piston-punk" verse if you will. Perhaps Cayley manages to sell the engines for industrial uses to gain revenue to allow him to continue experimenting with regards to flight.

Having the Pyréolophore as a successful model, Cayley continues to refine it after Claude's death. I don't think, given this scenario, that it would be unreasonable for a small enough Internal Combustion Engine to be developed by the late 1840's, especially if the Pyréolophore attracts the same interest as the steam engine did in OTL.

This will be where your major changes are going to be, as come Cayley's first powered flight in the late 1840's you will necessarily have widespread internal combustion engine use for trains, industrially, perhaps even for primitive automobiles. Cayley's flyer will attract significant attention and perhaps see use in TTL's tech-wanked Crimean war (along with armored cars, potential ironclads, etc.) as well as in the American Civil War (primarily by the Union).
 
Now that he has his engine and a machine that flies, he will have to modify his craft to stop crashing into hills due to a lack of inherent stability, and perhaps invent three-axis controls so that the craft can be steered. Note that Cayley made the machines but he never flew in them. Smart man. Perhaps a clockwork engine?
 
If Cayley tries to market combustion-powered locomotives, it'll be a serious threat to steam-engine builders, who will probably have the power to suppress his engine until the needs of major war bring it out. The airplanes (and maybe dirigibles) and combustion locomotives will then start to appear mid-1860's.:cool: Gasoline will be used earlier.
 
IOTL, George Cayley figured out how to make an airplane...


No he didn't. He built gliders, beautiful manned gliders which allowed him to be the first to identify several basic aerodynamic concepts, but he was far from making an "airplane".

... (he even did a few glider experiments) ...

And that's one of the reasons he was rather far from making an airplane; he did far too few glider experiments.

... but was unable to invent powered flight because he couldn't get the internal combustion engine to work.

No. Cayley lacked three things:

  • A sufficiently light and robust airframe
  • A sufficiently light and powerful engine
  • An understanding that powered flight is dynamic and requires constant control inputs from the pilot.


Cayley is prevented from achieving the first; the airframe, by the materials technology and construction techniques of his day. While Cayley actually invented "tension-spoke" wheels, the materials and techniques available to him meant he could not produce an airframe which would be light enough to fly while also being robust enough to carry an engine and withstand the stresses produced in flight.

Cayley is prevented from achieving the second; the engine, by the materials technology of the day. Dippy gunpowder fueled IC engines aside, metallurgy in 1825 was not up to the task of building a powerful engine that was also "light". Seventy five years later and decades after IC engines had entered general use, the Wrights were still rebuilding the IC engines available to them in order to increase those engines' horsepower to weight ratio.

Cayley is prevented from achieving the last; understanding the dynamic nature of flight, by his own lack of experimentation. As well as corresponding with flight researchers worldwide, the Wrights personally experimented with and flew gliders for years before attempting powered flight and their true breakthrough, the idea of dynamic control, was a result of all those years of painstaking experimentation. While they did allow him to identify several basic aerodynamic concepts, Cayley's handful of glider flights - none of which he actually piloted - simply weren't enough to give him the same insight the Wrights gained.

I cannot stress more strongly the importance of dynamic or three-axis control for powered flight. It was the Wright's true invention. Everyone else attempting to achieve powered flight, and there were thousands of them in the decades prior to 1903, had access to pretty much the same airframe and engine technology that the Wrights did. What made the Wrights was their insights into three-axis control and that put them years ahead of their competitors.

For example, while Santos-Dumont, another extremely important aviation pioneer, was loudly acclaimed in France for a single flight of a few hundred meters for less than 30 seconds in late 1906, the Wrights had already flown 40 kilometers for nearly 40 minutes in 1905.

It was the Wright's insight into three-axis control which gave them such a lead, a lead so great that when the Wrights finally flew in public in Europe in 1908 the nascent aviation community quickly tossed aside their own designs and adopted variations of the Wrights'.

So, Cayley sadly has three strikes against him, one conceptual and two technological. In order for him to overcome the first, Cayley is going to have to fly many more gliders much more often and either pilot them himself or use pilots who aren't children or farm hands. In order for him to overcome the last two, you'll need to advance technological progress so that Cayley has available to him what was available to the Wrights. That will require PODs which will change the 1825 of your time line all out of recognition and that makes your suggestions a non-starter.

Sorry.
 
Paddlewheel Aircraft Carrier

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Up4URX99-oM

?Wasn't there some one who invented a 2 cycle ICE in the 1820's? seems I remenbre a few threads about it.
Course you don't need ICE, it is possibe to do it with ECE.
Either a Steam powered Rotary Engine [ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKGy08OVxyM&NR=1 ]
or
Air like the first powered plane flight in 1895 [ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=voU3aRzOY7o&feature=related ]
or
With a converted compound steam car engine [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nw6NFmcnW-8 ]

Or
As the Fuel cell was invented in the 1820, then Cayley only has to invent a electric Motor [ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XzeCQblYHic&feature=related]
 
Last edited:
Top